Recently I wrote this and was prmpted to start a new thread. I would also like to give some cred to TruNorth for having such a friendly response when I basically said "I really hate you marketing project, it makes me angry".
I have wanted to say this for a very, very long time. It makes me really angry. Seriously, I have long rants about this to family and friends, they're probably getting sick of it by now. I can't stand it when people complain on chicken forums that their six month old roosters were tough when they BBQ'd or broiled them and the response is usually "oh, my (insert dual-purpose breed here) tasted great when I butchered them at 14 weeks but they were all bones, no meat". I really just want to say "let the birds grow till there's some meat on their bones, who cares how old it is as long as its less than a year. Then learn to cook it properly!" I also get a little upset when a prospective customer hangs up the phone or leaves the market without wanting one of my chickens just because I told them I won't be selling them a broiler, but this is more a sadness than an anger at their loss, since I don't really expect them to know any better.
Then I want them to read this: [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
I get so excited when Anna or I pull out our big clunky cast-iron roaster out of the cupboard and plop in a nice chicken from the freezer. Sometimes we put in a cup of rice and some chicken stock and cook the rice in the roasting juices. Sometimes we make a nice wheat flour seasoning and dry roast it. Sometimes I add a little wine, but that's more a thing for an even more awesome Muscovy roast! I'd pull out our gigantic cast-iron turkey roaster since the scovies are too huge and the mallard-derived's are too long for the chicken roaster but we just don't have a cast-iron one yet. Have I mentioned that every heritage breeders kitchen should contain a cast-iron roasting pot?
They crow, they fight. They try to get into the pen with the pullets so they can have some sex. (the hens are just as tasty, the're just usually laying by then and it's oh so tempting to keep all the hens for tasty eggs instead) They run around in circles for hours every day getting some nice dark meat on their thighs. The fat layer on those older lads is so wonderful and flavourful and I look forward to nabbing some crispy, fatty skin in my dinner. I live in a gastronomical dreamland because I get to eat all these heritage chickens and ducks. No wonder Slow Food chefs are only interested in Chanteclers and Buckeyes and Jersey Giants and the like. They're all sitting in their offices salivating at the thought!
See how easily I went from anger to food lust just thinking about roasting a heritage chicken. My point stand though despite my hunger. Broilers and roasting heritage chickens should not be compared, ever. Broiler does not equal meat bird, it equals chicken killed really young.
Country Thyme Farm wrote:
Now I'm going to open a big can o' worms that I have been dutifully avoiding for so long, but this has pushed me over the edge.
"Rustic broilers", which I will admit is a clever marketing scheme, are I believe doing far more harm to heritage poultry right now than Greenfire Farms is ever going to be capable of. We finally had so many people getting sick and tired of frankenchickens that they were starting to look at heritage dual-purpose birds as a viable alternative to meat production. Now here some people come along saying "oh look, I have this rustic broiler, it makes such a nicer meat bird than all those crappy heritage birds cause they take so long and it's a different colour so can feel like your raising something less horrific" Now all those people with open minds that we could have had as allies in saving traditional meat breeds from extinction by raising them for their actual intended use are now lost to us again because it has been reaffirmed to them that "meat bird" has a different definition than "heritage chicken".
1. It's just a freaking broiler with crappier feed conversion and a slower growth rate that hasn't been inbred quite long enough to cause the other usual health problems!
2. Heritage meat birds aren't broilers at all! Stop trying to treat them like broilers! Heritage meat chickens are roasting chickens! They have actual fat on their bodies and their meat has enough texture to actually justify calling it meat. I can't even make "tastes like chicken" jokes because it actually tastes like something and that something is pure awesome!
Ok, I feel better now.
I have wanted to say this for a very, very long time. It makes me really angry. Seriously, I have long rants about this to family and friends, they're probably getting sick of it by now. I can't stand it when people complain on chicken forums that their six month old roosters were tough when they BBQ'd or broiled them and the response is usually "oh, my (insert dual-purpose breed here) tasted great when I butchered them at 14 weeks but they were all bones, no meat". I really just want to say "let the birds grow till there's some meat on their bones, who cares how old it is as long as its less than a year. Then learn to cook it properly!" I also get a little upset when a prospective customer hangs up the phone or leaves the market without wanting one of my chickens just because I told them I won't be selling them a broiler, but this is more a sadness than an anger at their loss, since I don't really expect them to know any better.
Then I want them to read this: [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
I get so excited when Anna or I pull out our big clunky cast-iron roaster out of the cupboard and plop in a nice chicken from the freezer. Sometimes we put in a cup of rice and some chicken stock and cook the rice in the roasting juices. Sometimes we make a nice wheat flour seasoning and dry roast it. Sometimes I add a little wine, but that's more a thing for an even more awesome Muscovy roast! I'd pull out our gigantic cast-iron turkey roaster since the scovies are too huge and the mallard-derived's are too long for the chicken roaster but we just don't have a cast-iron one yet. Have I mentioned that every heritage breeders kitchen should contain a cast-iron roasting pot?
They crow, they fight. They try to get into the pen with the pullets so they can have some sex. (the hens are just as tasty, the're just usually laying by then and it's oh so tempting to keep all the hens for tasty eggs instead) They run around in circles for hours every day getting some nice dark meat on their thighs. The fat layer on those older lads is so wonderful and flavourful and I look forward to nabbing some crispy, fatty skin in my dinner. I live in a gastronomical dreamland because I get to eat all these heritage chickens and ducks. No wonder Slow Food chefs are only interested in Chanteclers and Buckeyes and Jersey Giants and the like. They're all sitting in their offices salivating at the thought!
See how easily I went from anger to food lust just thinking about roasting a heritage chicken. My point stand though despite my hunger. Broilers and roasting heritage chickens should not be compared, ever. Broiler does not equal meat bird, it equals chicken killed really young.